Timeless Supreme

Timeless Supreme 650

Shape Toro
Size 6 x 50
Strength Medium - Full
Box Pressed Yes
Wrapper Nicaraguan Habano
Binder / Filler Nicaragua / Nicaragua
Color Colorado
Grade Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Blender Michael Herklots
Country of Origin Nicaragua
SKU TSFT-01-154E
$270.90
$243.80
(You save $27.10)
In Stock
Package Qty (Select Product Option) Required

Create Wish List

Nat Sherman Timeless Supreme 

Originally created by Nat Sherman, the Timeless Supreme is now part of the former vice president of Nat Sherman Cigars Michael Herklots and his newly found cigar company Ferio Tego Cigar Co. The 95-rated Timeless Supreme is a very balanced box-pressed cigar made entirely of Nicaraguan tobaccos at the Matasa factory. The blend delivers great Nicaraguan flavors of spice that are rounded out with a smooth creaminess. Each vitola comes packaged in 21-count boxes.
 
Buy Timeless Supreme Cigars by Ferio Tego Cigar Co. Online from AtlanticCigar.com, the Leader in Discount Cigar Prices. Shop our Site Today for the Best Cigar Prices on the Net! Always Shipped Fast & Fresh Right to Your Door. 
Shape:
Toro
Size:
6 x 50
Strength:
Medium - Full
Box Pressed:
Yes
Wrapper:
Nicaraguan Habano
Binder / Filler:
Nicaragua / Nicaragua
Color:
Colorado
Grade:
Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Blender:
Michael Herklots
Country of Origin:
Nicaragua

Product Reviews

Score: 5 out of 5 (based on 1 rating)
Write a Review
5/5
Perfection
Written by William C on Feb 15th 2026

The Ferio Tego Timeless Supreme 650 is an absolute standout in my humidor right now—a true Nicaraguan puro that delivers everything I look for in a premium cigar. From the moment you pull it out, the box-pressed toro (6” x 50) looks stunning: a beautiful reddish-brown wrapper that’s oily, veiny in just the right way, and impeccably constructed with no soft spots or flaws. The pre-light aroma is rich and inviting—think cocoa, leather, and a hint of sweet spice. Lighting up is effortless, with a perfect draw and an even burn that holds steady from start to finish. This cigar is medium-full to full-bodied, packing plenty of power without ever becoming overwhelming. The flavor profile is complex and harmonious: right away you get lush notes of rich toffee, cocoa powder, and toasted marshmallow that blend seamlessly, layered with underlying nuttiness, cedar, and a touch of warm spice. As it progresses, those dessert-like sweetnesses deepen, finishing with a big, satisfying nutty close that’s clean and lingering. What really impresses me is how balanced and refined it feels for such a bold smoke—strong and resonant, yet never harsh. Every puff builds on the last, keeping things interesting for the full 90+ minutes this toro provides. It’s no surprise it earned a 95-point rating from Cigar Aficionado and landed at #10 on their Top 25 list—it’s that good. If you’re into full-flavored Nicaraguan cigars that offer depth, consistency, and pure enjoyment, the Timeless Supreme 650 is a must-try. Highly recommended—easily one of the best I’ve smoked recently.