Save Room for These Thanksgiving Cigar and Drink Pairings

Somewhere between your second helping of stuffing and your first slice of pie, you start thinking about that Thanksgiving cigar. You’ve been eating and drinking with friends and family since somebody opened the wine in the kitchen.

Now the turkey’s picked over, the pie’s finally made it around the table, and nobody’s in much of a hurry to go home. Take a couple of chairs out to the porch and let somebody finish the story they started over dinner. You’ve got time for a cigar.

We kept the cigars compact so you can step out for a smoke and get back to the guests who stayed inside. As for which one to light, start with what’s in your glass.

Thanksgiving Nightcaps and the Cigars to Match

Dry hard cider with Macanudo Café Ascots Tins

Macanudo Cafe Ascot Tins

After pumpkin pie and whipped cream, pour a dry hard cider with enough tartness to cut through the sweetness. The sharp apple goes well with the creamy, nutty notes Macanudo describes in its Café blend. The slim, mild Macanudo Café Ascot suits a short spell outside.

At the store, start with a bottle marked dry. A cider can smell like ripe apples and still finish tart, so trust the first sip. The Ascots come in a tin of ten, which comes in handy when a couple more people decide they’re coming out with you.

Macanudo Café Ascots Buy Button

Dry sherry with Plasencia Reserva Original

Plasencia Reserva Original Cigar

A glass of Amontillado dry sherry is worth pouring for anyone who went back for more stuffing. Its dry finish is welcome after buttery sides. The sherry’s hazelnut aroma goes with the bread and nut notes Plasencia describes in Reserva Original. Pour it slightly chilled and give yourself time for the Plasencia Reserva Original Corona Corta. At 48 ring gauge, it’s considerably thicker than the Ascot, even though it’s shorter.

Amontillado is a good bottle to have open before the cigars come out. Serve it to anyone still working on the cheese plate, then take your glass with you when you head outside. Anyone who usually drinks sweet cream sherry might do a double take at the first sip.

Plasencia Reserva Original Corona Corta Buy Button

Beaujolais-Villages with Joya Red Short Churchill

Joya Red Short Churchill Cigar

Bring the Beaujolais-Villages you poured with the turkey out to the porch and light a Joya Red Short Churchill. The wine’s berry notes are a good follow-up to cranberry sauce. Joya de Nicaragua describes the blend as nutty with a little pepper, which gives the fruit a savory edge.

The Short Churchill is only 4¾ inches long with a 48 ring gauge, which puts it close to a Robusto in size. Joya rates the blend at medium strength. It’s one to set out alongside the Ascots for guests who like a little pepper and want something they can spend more time with.

Joya Red Short Churchill Buy Button

Dark lager with HVC Hot Cake Golden Line

HVC Hot Cake Golden Line Cigar

Ayinger Altbairisch Dunkel is a good follow-up to roasted sweet potatoes, especially the browned bits at the edge of the pan. The lager’s roasted malt goes with the toasted almond notes we list for the HVC Hot Cake Golden Line Connecticut Laguito No. 4. The hint of vanilla in the blend picks up the sweetness of the potatoes.

For a beer in the same style as the Ayinger, look for Dunkel on the label. A good match here has a soft roast, like the browned edge of a piece of toast. A heavier roast can drown out the cigar’s softer flavors.

HVC Hot Cake Golden Line Connecticut Laguito No. 4 Buy Button

Cognac with Charter Oak Maduro Rothschild

Charter Oak Maduro Rothschild Cigar

Save the Rémy Martin 1738 Accord Royal for after the pecan pie. The cognac maker’s notes of toffee and oak pick up where the toasted nuts and browned crust left off. Foundation describes the Charter Oak Maduro as earthy with some sweetness. The earthiness gives the cognac’s toffee a savory edge, and the 4½ × 50 Rothschild is a good choice when you want a richer smoke in a smaller size.

Give the cognac a sip before you light up. If the alcohol is all you notice at first, try it over a cube of ice and give it a minute. Take another sip between puffs and see what you pick up from the drink and what you taste in the tobacco.

Charter Oak Maduro Rothschild Buy Button

A Pairing Worth Repeating

Pour a little more of the drink you liked best at dinner, or open something you’ve been saving. Take a sip once you’ve had a few puffs and see what the cigar brings out in the glass. You might find a pairing worth bringing back next Thanksgiving. For now, you’ve got a little more time together before everybody starts looking for their coats.

About the Author

The Atlantic Cigar Staff is a team of seasoned cigar aficionados with over 25 years of experience. As part of the Atlantic Cigar family for decades, our team lives and breathes premium cigars.

We keep a close eye on what our customers are buying, reordering, and raving about. The data tells us a lot about which cigars truly stand out. Then we smoke them ourselves to see how they stack up. Every recommendation comes from a mix of real customer insights and first-hand experience.

Between decades in the industry and plenty of time spent with a lit cigar in hand, our team shares honest opinions to help both seasoned smokers and curious newcomers discover something worth adding to the humidor.