Few names in cigars carry the recognition of Romeo y Julieta. You may have known the name long before you ever smoked your first cigar. With roots stretching back to Havana in 1875 and a history that counts Winston Churchill among its admirers, Romeo y Julieta has earned a place in any conversation about the great names in cigars.
For a brand with so much history, Romeo y Julieta still gives you plenty of reasons to try something new. You can keep things mellow and creamy or go looking for more spice and strength. Even if you\’ve been buying the same box for years, another side of Romeo might be worth making room for in your humidor.
We\’ve handpicked five of our favorite non-Cuban Romeo y Julieta cigars, drawing on customer purchase history and choosing a mix of blends, strengths, and sizes. Here\’s what makes each one worth a place on your list.
A Brief History of Romeo y Julieta
Romeo y Julieta borrowed its name from Shakespeare\’s famous lovers when it began in Havana in 1875. By 1903, Jos\é \“Pep\ín\” Rodr\íguez Fern\ández had taken over and was putting his own stamp on the business. Personalized cigar bands for prominent customers helped turn a good smoke into a calling card. Pep\ín understood the value of getting a memorable name into the right hands, and Romeo y Julieta\’s reputation spread well beyond Cuba.
After the Cuban Revolution, the story split into two branches: Cuban Romeo y Julieta and a separate brand serving the U.S. market. Production for the U.S. brand began in the Dominican Republic in 1970, with Honduran and Nicaraguan blends joining the family later. Today, that familiar name covers quite a range of tobacco and flavor. Knowing which Romeo you\’re picking up makes all the difference, so let\’s get to the cigars.
Our Five Favorite Romeo y Julieta Cigars
1. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Magnum

Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
Shape: Gordo
Size: 6 x 60
Strength: Mild to Medium
Grade: Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Binder / Filler: Nicaragua / Dominican Republic, Nicaragua
Wrapper Type: Ecuadorian Connecticut
The Reserva Real Magnum is a good starting point if you enjoy a creamy cigar with a larger ring gauge. Its 6 x 60 format gives you plenty of cigar to settle in with, while the mild-to-medium strength keeps it approachable.
An Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper surrounds a Nicaraguan binder and Dominican and Nicaraguan filler. The blend gives the creamy profile some body without taking it into the stronger territory of the Reserva Real Nicaragua.
The Magnum earns its place here for fans of a thicker cigar who still prefer a gentler smoke.
2. Romeo y Julieta Reserve Toro

Country of Origin: Honduras
Shape: Toro
Size: 6 x 56
Strength: Medium to Full
Grade: Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Binder / Filler: Nicaragua / Honduras, Nicaragua
Wrapper Type: Nicaraguan
The Reserve Toro is our pick for someone who likes a fuller Romeo with some earth and pepper. Its Nicaraguan wrapper and binder surround Honduran and Nicaraguan filler, giving you a different blend from the Dominican cigars on this list.
Natural sweetness rounds out the earthy profile, so there\’s more to it than spice. At 6 x 56, the Toro has a substantial feel in the hand without going quite as wide as the Magnum.
If you\’ve only tried the milder side of Romeo y Julieta, the Reserve is a good place to explore a fuller blend.
3. Romeo y Julieta 1875 Bully

Country of Origin: Dominican Republic
Shape: Robusto
Size: 5 x 50
Strength: Mild to Medium
Grade: Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Binder / Filler: Dominican Republic / Dominican Republic
Wrapper Type: Indonesian Sumatra
The 1875 Bully is the one we\’d reach for when recommending a classic Romeo in a familiar Robusto size. At 5 x 50, it gives you a full-sized cigar without the larger dimensions of the Magnum or Reserve Toro.
Its Indonesian Sumatra wrapper covers Dominican binder and filler, producing a mellow flavor profile with medium body. The blend is a useful starting point if you\’re getting acquainted with Romeo y Julieta or simply prefer a cigar that goes easy on strength.
Choose the Bully for its manageable size and traditional 1875 blend.
4. Romeo y Julieta 1875 Mini Blue Mild Tins

Country of Origin: Spain
Shape: Cigarillo
Packaging: Case of 100, packed in five tins of 20
Wrapper Type: Indonesian
Filler: Dominican
Some days, a full-sized cigar asks for more time than you have. The Mini Blue tins earn their place here by offering a small cigar you can reach for during a shorter break.
An Indonesian wrapper and Dominican filler give these cigarillos a profile with cream, cedar, and toasted nuts. The compact format is the reason to choose them, especially if you enjoy keeping a tin handy alongside your larger cigars.
For a full-sized cigar with a mellow profile, take a look at the 1875 Bully above.
5. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Nicaragua Toro

Country of Origin: Nicaragua
Shape: Toro
Size: 6 x 54
Strength: Medium to Full
Grade: Hand Rolled / Long Filler
Binder / Filler: Nicaragua / Nicaragua
Wrapper Type: Nicaraguan Habano
The Reserva Real Nicaragua Toro is our choice for fans of Nicaraguan tobacco. A.J. Fernandez and Rafael Nodal developed the blend using Nicaraguan wrapper, binder, and filler, with production at Tabacalera A.J. Fernandez in Estel\í.
It has more body than the original Dominican Reserva Real, with leather, sweet nuts, spice, and a woody finish. If you like a cigar with some sweetness alongside its stronger character, the Toro gives you a reason to look beyond the familiar red band.
The exact 6 x 54 Toro earned 92 points and the No. 22 spot in Cigar Aficionado’s Top 25 of 2020. Its all-Nicaraguan blend makes it a useful comparison with the Honduran-made Reserve Toro above.
For more from the man behind this blend, explore our picks for the best AJ Fernandez cigars.
Find Your Favorite Romeo y Julieta
Your favorite Romeo y Julieta will come down to what you enjoy smoking. Start with the strength and size you usually reach for, then let your curiosity take it from there. A brand with this much variety deserves a little room in the humidor for something you haven\’t tried yet.
Looking to explore another familiar name? Browse our best Montecristo cigars, or find more options in our guide to premium cigars under $10.
About the Author
The Atlantic Cigar Staff is a team of seasoned cigar aficionados with over 25 years of experience. As part of the Atlantic Cigar family for decades, our team lives and breathes premium cigars.
We keep a close eye on what our customers are buying, reordering, and raving about. The data tells us a lot about which cigars truly stand out. Then we smoke them ourselves to see how they stack up. Every recommendation comes from a mix of real customer insights and first-hand experience.
Between decades in the industry and plenty of time spent with a lit cigar in hand, our team shares honest opinions to help both seasoned smokers and curious newcomers discover something worth adding to the humidor.